Category Archives: General Environmental Reference

Larimer Alliance Speaks to the Climate Activists of Tomorrow at Dunn Elementary Dolphin Dash Event

Fifth Graders getting ready to visit their chosen pledge stations.

Visitors to the Larimer Alliance Station on Climate Change Knowledge

The Larimer Alliance had a unique opportunity to speak with the next generation of potential climate activists. On May 3, we set up an informational table at Dunn Elementary, a unique school that is part of the globally recognized International Baccalaureate program based in over 5,000 schools in 158 countries. Our display and discussion were part of Dunn’s Dolphin Dash and Learner Profile Pledge event.

Starting with Fifth Graders in the morning, groups of up to ten students selected to visit tables to visit focusing on hunger, social justice, reading and education, affordable energy, water quality, and air quality. The students are seeking ways to tie what they are learning in Dunn’s IB program to these issues and what they can do to work on them. In speaking of the Alliance’s work, we emphasized air quality and how it is affected along the Front Range by oil and gas activity.

A large number of those who visited the Larimer Alliance table indicated they had picked up trash and/or planted trees and native plants for Earth Day and were aware of the need to shift off fossil fuels. By the end of the day with the kindergarten kiddos, we were just asking some pretty basic questions. But all the students expressed understanding of the various issues, and recognized they will be working on them in the future. It is encouraging to see them paying attention. . .

Certified Disaster: a powerful report hits home

See the link below to download this 43 page PDF report that is totally focused on the pressing issue of air pollution in the Front Range:

CERTIFIED DISASTER: HOW PROJECT CANARY & GAS CERTIFICATION ARE MISLEADING MARKETS & GOVERNMENTS

Though originally published in April 2023 (when it was reported here), I thought it would be a timely reminder to help support public pressure on our state legislators and local legislators. It was so incredibly informative, I felt the need to post it here again. (Note that the cover image is from Weld County, from an OGI video filmed by Earthworks.)

The title says it all: the O&G industry is trying with all its powerful media might to lie to local governments and US domestic markets about the pollution it is causing. They have hired a host of PR efforts to spread their lies, which is wrapped up in something called Project Canary. Purposefully name to allude to the aphorism of a canary in a coal mine, the old fashioned method of detecting deadly methane gas in the hand-dug coal mines of old.

But this quote from page 29 gives the lie of this project. Though organized under the auspices of the Colorado School of Mines in Golden, the industry keeps the project muzzled and its data hidden:

“But the data is not made available for public verification, and Project
Canary’s methods have not been subjected to peer review….At the moment, proprietary quantification methods can be a bit of a black box, and it’s not easy to get information on the methods used,” argues Professor Allen. “So it needs academic oversight but with the
process being led by regulators to ensure compliance. And methodologies should be peer-reviewed. The emissions data should be public – at least to regulators. This would be the gold standard that could build trust and transparency in any data.”

Another expert opinion: “One expert, who prefers to remain anonymous, states that “the claims that Project Canary is making regarding being
able to track all methane emissions seem to be premature and should be backed up by peer-reviewed science so they can be independently validated.”

In other words: the public, nor the regulators, nor the markets, can trust the data coming out Project Canary.

The report goes on to document how the entire project is suspect due to the conflict of interest built into the so-called “certification” that it offers to O&G projects. It is the old story of regulatory capture…or the fox guarding the hen house, to put the situation in the vernacular.

So if anyone from the O&G industry attempts to offer up Project Canary as a defense of how their projects have been “certified”…or that their boundary fence monitors are protecting the public health…this is malarky! Their bluff should be called, and regulators should demand peer reviewed science and real transparency to their data and measurement methods…like real science, not fake science.

Patagonia sponsors local activists fighting ozone pollution by…running?

Fighting air pollution by running? Yes, there is such a thing…and I and Ed Behan attended this event that proved it is happening.

Ed & I at Patagonia Boulder…where we didn’t realize we were being photo-bombed!

On Friday night, February 9, 2024, Ed Behan and I drove down from Fort Collins to the Patagonia store in Boulder. ‘Step Up for Air’ was sponsored Colorado Rising, Suffer Better and the Colorado Regional Air Quality Council. It was billed as the “RUFA Pre-Race Event this year!” on their Facebook page. (RUFA, if you couldn’t guess, is Run Up For Air — of course!)

Neither I nor Ed are runners, of course; we were there for the free food and drink, and the chance to meet other activists in person.

The event was slow to get started…because some of the participants were still out on a run!

Talked with Christiaan van Hooteberg and Brent Goodlet, both local activists. Christiaan is with the Erie Protectors, and actually was on Erie’s city council for 4 years recently. He’s an IT guy, and informed me he has downloaded the ENTIRE ECMC database, and is using the information to good effect! He showed me a cool map he had made recently of all the wells, included the underground horizontal well bores, that are in the Erie vicinity — an alarming graphic which looks a crowded pincushion. I hope to work with him in the future.

The main organizer of the event, Patrick, with Run Up for Air, encouraged people to sign up for a local running event, coming up soon — this group seems to prefer running in the winter! — which would raise money for this environmental cause.

Patrick’s introduction was followed by an excellent film made by Patagonia about the origins and continuing winter running event in Salt Lake City by a 24 hr run up and down Grandeur Mountain. Started about 10 years ago, the type of event has spread to a few other cities scattered across the West, for the same purpose: calling attention to air pollution and raising money to help develop legislation to change it.

Next were several presentations by local representatives who are working on this. I did not get a picture of the presentation by the representative from the Regional Air Quality Council, but who vouched that the issue if of real concern to local governments; however, her presentation lacked information about what can be done to remedy the situation.

The next two presenters did address this question:

This is Jared Bynum of Colorado Rising, who gave quite an animated delievery of why the impacts of fracking so harmful, but which has been allowed to affect so many residential communities in the Front Range.

Helena Gonzalez of Conservation Colorado gave a quite thorough walkthrough of current analysis they use in their lobbying of the Colorado legislature. They are tackling the O&G industry head-on, and presenting the strong case for why they are the primary cause of our ozone pollution problem — and helping to develop the necessary legislation to correct it.

Poster of why surface level ozone is not good for you! Very good to see this detailed information getting out to the public.

The evening ended in a raffle, where a lucky few won some good gear.

And with that, Ed and I drove home in a snowstorm back up the Fort Collins. It was worth it!

WORLD CANCER DAY

February 4th of each year is World Cancer Day. For the last two years, activists have focused on equity in cancer treatment and closing the care gap. Worldwide, most cancer deaths come from low-income countries. Even in developed countries like the USA, low-income and minority communities are disproportionately impacted by cancer1

Many cancer cases and deaths can be prevented through early detection and good treatment. However, not only does equitable healthcare need to be addressed, but also the infrastructural problems that allow risks of cancer among low-income and minority communities to be high in the first place. 

The Global Fight

Low-income and minority communities are often disproportionally affected by oil and gas development. 

Recently, both Amnesty International and Human Rights Watch published reports on the fossil fuel and petrochemical industry’s invasion of southeast Texas and the aptly named “Cancer Alley” in southern Louisiana.

The communities most affected by pollution-spewing companies in both states are majority Black, Hispanic, and/or low-income. In the Lousiana St. James Parish, oil and gas facilities have been exclusively placed in majority-Black districts over the last 46 years2.

One 57-year-old woman, Angie Roberts, interviewed by Human Rights Watch, claims to feel much older than she is. She has already had breast cancer once and has developed the autoimmune disorder, Multiple Sclerosis (MS has been linked to petrochemical emissions). Her son works temporarily in a nearby petrochemical plant, which came to the area years after the family had already bought their house. They keep their blinds drawn because the view of the billowing industrial sites just reminds them of the fact that they can’t move. No one would want to buy their house for enough money to give them a chance at moving somewhere else2

In Houston a lack of zoning regulations allows industrial facilities to be placed near residential areas, where the populations are majority-Black/Hispanic. According to Amnesty International, “The average life expectancy in some affected neighborhoods is up to 20 years lower than in majority white communities just 15 miles away.”3

According to the reports, a cocktail of chemicals is sent into the air, water, and land daily due to oil production and storage, fertilizer and pesticide manufacturing, and petrochemical production (the separation of natural gas into benzene, prothelyne, methanol, etc)2.

Benzene is often released through waterways or during flaring (releasing excess gas, rather than containing it) and is a known human carcinogen (cancer-causing chemical). According to the EPA and World Health Organization, there are no safe exposure levels or routes of Benzene2. Because Benzene can be inhaled or ingested, after which it enters the bloodstream, Leukemia is the most common form of cancer linked to chronic Benzene exposure. Ambient exposure levels can cause a myriad of short-term health effects, like drowsiness, dizziness, and headaches, as well as eye, skin, and respiratory tract irritation.2,4

The Local Fight

While many of the largest environmental injustices are occurring in Texas and Louisiana, the oil and gas industry’s unjust polluting is not just a problem for the Deep South. Here in Colorado, we too face unjust polluting measures from oil and gas companies. In Commerce City, in Northern Denver, the Suncor oil refinery reportedly releases more unplanned pollution and has more frequent malfunctions than comparable oil refineries across the country5. Such shutdowns, like the multiple in December 2023 and January 2024 through the cold freezes cause the company to unexpectedly release Hydrogen Sulfide, Carbon Monoxide, and Sulfur Dioxide, the amounts of which often override their permitted allowances6

Hydrogen Sulfide, in low chronic amounts, can cause respiratory and eye irritation, headaches and dizziness. In one study, hydrogen sulfide exposure was linked to elevated rates of nasal cancers7,8.  

While Carbon Monoxide and Sulfur Dioxide are not human carcinogens, exposure can cause respiratory problems, headaches, dizziness, and fatigue. 

Suncor releases up to 3.5 million gallons of polluted water daily into Sand Creek. Contaminated groundwater from the Suncor property also has the potential to leak into the Burlington Ditch, for which it does not have a permit. The Burlington Ditch originally flows from Barr Lake State Park before making it into Commerce City, where shortly after the Suncor industrial site, it flows directly into the South Platte River and through parks and residential areas. In May 2023 the containment area overflowed during a storm and released toxic water into the ditch4

Most commonly reported in Suncor’s water waste are Benzene and polyfluoroalkyl substances (PFAS). PFAS are used to make Fluropolymere coatings and water-, heat-, oil-, and stain-resistant products2. These chemicals are ingested through food or water and build up in the body because their compounds do not decompose. The EPA says that while research on the health effects is rapidly developing, they can cause cancer in the kidneys, prostate and testicles, among other health problems like lowering women’s fertility and creating developmental delays in children4

It’s no surprise that these egregious pollution events are taking place in the marginalized, majority Hispanic/low-income Commerce City Neighborhood of Elyria-Swansea. 

If that doesn’t hit close to home, what does is finding out that both of these waterways supply drinking water and water for agriculture to the northeast,  Commerce City and Thornton4. It’s tough to realize that we are exposed to the pollutants Suncor is releasing no matter where we live in Colorado. 

In Fort Collins in 2021, an oil and gas site was found to have been illegally venting volatile organic chemicals (VOCs)13, which can include Benzene, for years. After many residential complaints and four previous state-level enforcement actions, the site was ordered to “cease and desist” in August 20229 but the order only lasted for three months!

VOCs are part of the reason why northern Colorado has some of the highest ozone levels in the country.  This is due to our state’s inversion-causing geography and the concentrated oil and gas industry activity in the Front Range, especially in Weld County. The American Lung Association says ozone pollution causes breathing disorders, lung cancer, and also contributes to pre-term births and low birth weights as well as heart attacks and strokes10.

Again in October 2023, a produced water injection line was reported to have a leaky connection. Produced water is the wastewater that returns to the surface after fracking. It can include radium, arsenic, hydrocarbons, and other remains of chemicals that were injected into the well to aid in the oil extraction process. Many of the added chemicals are carcinogenic and radium and arsenic are known human carcinogens11

Summary

World Cancer Day activists have a lot to go up against this year. Statistically, the people facing the most damaging effects of the fossil fuel industry are low-income and facing many barriers to good health care12. Cancer is truly a systemic issue, which needs to be prioritized and addressed by policymakers from the bottom up. Only then can we have the hope of enjoying a cancer-free world for everyone. 

Sources: 

  1. https://www.worldcancerday.org/why-cancer
  2. Human Rights Watch “We’re Dying Here” Report 
  3. Amnesty International “The Cost of Doing Bussiness” Report 
  4. ‘“Forever chemicals” flowing from Suncor into Sand Creek spike as Colorado weighs renewal of key water-quality permit” By Noelle Phillips
  5. Suncor has more pollution problems than similar U.S. refineries, new EPA report finds By Sam Brasch
  6. Suncor’s Commerce City refinery reported more than a dozen pollutant-spewing malfunctions since December By Noelle Phillips
  7.  https://doi.org/10.1080/00039890109604063 By Marvin S. Legator , Chantele R. Singleton , Debra L. Morris & Donna L. Philips
  8. https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/9563687/ By M N Bates 1, N Garrett, B Graham, D Read
  9. https://cdphe.colorado.gov/press-release/state-issues-cease-and-desist-order-for-prospect-energy-krause-site
  10.  https://www.lung.org/research/sota/health-risks
  11. https://sites.google.com/view/larimeralliance/news/og-in-northeast-foco?authuser=0
  12. https://www.fightcancer.org/policy-resources/costs-cancer-people-limited-incomes-0
  13. Footage of Prospect Energy’s Illegal Emissions By Andrew Klooster